The Washington Post's June 18 news story on the National Council on Teacher Quality report quoted Arthur Levine, the former president of Teachers College, as saying: "We don't know how to prepare teachers. We can't decide whether it's a craft or a profession. Do you need a lot of education as you would in a profession, or do you need a little bit and then learn on the job, like a craft?"
I agree with Levine, but I think his remarks expose a false dichotomy that could be reconciled if the political and academic will existed to do so.
To see why the teaching world need not choose between training craftspeople or professionals, look to medicine.
In this country, medical students go to school for four years of highly specialized education. They spend their first two years learning the fundamentals and the theories of medicine. Their second two years are spent mainly in clinical rotations, learning the craft of patient care through observation and guided practice.
Students also take the first two steps in a series of rigorous licensing exams that test their theoretical and practical knowledge. If they survive the schooling and the tests, they proceed to on-the-job learning under the tutelage of master practitioners and take more tests.
Only after they have made it through the required intellectual and practical education are they considered qualified to practice medicine. No one would question that they are professionals. The hands-on portion of their training is also indispensable.
Why not adopt this model for education? Educators could be required to complete a period of schooling in which they learn the theories and ideas that will be most valuable to them as teachers and hone their skills at thinking and talking about education from an intellectual standpoint.
Then, perhaps, one to two years of guided practice under the supervision of master teachers could be required, with lots of coaching and meaningful feedback. We could even throw in some rigorous exams.
In a few years, it would be possible to see whether our teaching corps and our schools have improved dramatically. My guess is that we would all be pleasantly surprised.
Dimyan-Ehrenfeld practices education and civil rights law in Washington. She taught for eight years in public schools in Prince George's County and in Boston.