For the Monarchs, the 2012 champions who were eliminated by Wheeling Park in a regional final, infielder Kylie Howard caps her career with a fourth consecutive first-team nod.
"She's probably the most talented and most athletic player we've ever had," JM Coach Ed West said. "She's been very good, very consistent, and she can beat you in a lot of ways. If she's not getting hits and driving in runs, she's making plays on defense and getting people out. She does a lot of good things."
Monarchs pitcher Amy Rotriga earns her third consecutive selection after being named second team her freshman season, and Alyssa George made the club as an outfielder.
Howard, who injured her knee in basketball, rallied to hit .400 with 10 doubles, eight triples and 36 RBI, while the left-handed Rotriga capped her senior season with an 0.99 ERA in 155.3 innings, striking out 278 batters along the way.
George, a junior, led the Monarchs with a team-best 38 RBI while batting .414 with four home runs.
Though George will be back, Rotriga, Howard and catcher Kristin Lewicki (the 2013 captain of the second team) leave as leaders of JM teams that went a combined 65-8 the last two seasons, had winning streaks of 24, and 29, and went to three state tournaments.
"They've been an excellent group, both on the field and off the field," West said. "They've been a pleasure to coach and pleasure to watch for four years."
Rounding out the pitchers are St. Albans senior Ali Haynes, the state's leader with 27 victories who had 166 strikeouts and a 1.25 ERA in 191 innings, South Charleston's Alli Burdette, a repeat first teamer who went 19-8 with a state-best 326 strikeouts in 176 innings, Morgantown's Tara Hanson (11-4, 85 strikeouts, 0.55 ERA with 11 complete games), whose only losses came to John Marshall and Wheeling Park, and Ripley junior Chelsey Hager, who went 10-4 in the circle with a 1.05 ERA.
Haynes, who also hit .442 with five homers, 44 RBI, and 18 doubles, was the second team captain in 2012.
Joining Howard in the infield is Wheeling Park's Carly Greer, a junior pitcher/first baseman who batted .381 with a pair of homers and 18 RBI to go along with 77 strikeouts in 92 innings pitched, Morgan Zerkle (.647, BA, 4 HR, 23 RBI, 59 runs) and Morgan Kelley (.456, 8 HR, 54 RBI) of Cabell Midland, and MacKenzie Milam (.641, 6 HR, 39 RBI) of Shady Spring. Kelley is a repeat first teamer, while Zerkle also accomplished the feat in 2011 as a sophomore.
Grabbing the other two utility spots were Jefferson's Alexandra Witt (.447, 8 HR) and Parkersburg's Brittany Allison (.427, 7 HR, 26 RBI).
St. Albans senior Mariah Caudill (.442, 4 HR, 55 RBI) is the club's other catcher.
Lewicki, John Marshall's leading hitter at .524, including 45 singles from her leadoff spot, was named to the second team for a third straight year.